| Platinum | Divicious Deli & Coffee Shop |
| Gold | Fat Jack's Deli & Pub |
| Silver | Subs N Such |
| Bronze | Uncle Nick's Italian Deli, Bagels and Catering |
| Top Pick | America's Best Cuban Sandwich |
| Top Pick | Britt's Cafe |
| Top Pick | Jason's Deli |
| Top Pick | Salem's Fresh Eats |
| Top Pick | Strawberry Hut |
| Top Pick | The Honeybaked Ham Company |