| Platinum | J Burns Pizza |
| Gold | Romeo's Pizza & Pasta |
| Silver | Mellow Mushroom Lakeland |
| Bronze | Il Forno Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria - Northside |
| Top Pick | By The Chef Pizza |
| Top Pick | Kc's Artisan Pizza |
| Top Pick | Palace Pizza |
| Top Pick | Primo's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Twin Peaks |
| Top Pick | Wabash Pizzeria and Ice Cream |