| Platinum | America's Best Cuban Sandwich |
| Gold | Divicious Deli & Coffee Shop |
| Silver | Strawberry Hut |
| Bronze | Ole' Tampa Cubans |
| Top Pick | Castro's Cafe |
| Top Pick | Cuban Delights Cafe |
| Top Pick | Elena's Cuban Cafe |
| Top Pick | Nineteen61 |
| Top Pick | West Caribbean Cuban Restaurant |